Playbook

AI adoption playbook & pilot templates

A practical, stage-based playbook to assess, run, validate, and scale AI pilots in research settings. Includes milestone criteria, a complete pilot planning template (metrics, sample-size guidance), a risk & validation checklist, a roles & responsibilities matrix, and example retrospective and scale checklists. Recommended interactive forms and data-capture points are noted for easier reuse and reproducibility.

AI adoption playbook & pilot templates

This playbook helps research teams bring AI into reproducible research workflows through staged pilots, clear success criteria, and risk-aware governance. It is meant to be practical: copy the templates, run a small, well-instrumented pilot, learn, and then either iterate or scale.

Why this matters

AI can accelerate research but also introduce irreproducibility, hidden bias, and wasted effort when used ad hoc. The playbook encourages small, measurable experiments that integrate with reproducible pipelines, explicit validation steps, and governance checkpoints before broader adoption.

High-level stages and milestone criteria

  1. Assess

    Goal: Identify candidate AI opportunities and screen for feasibility, data readiness, and potential impact.

    Milestones: clear problem statement, available labeled data or feasible labeling plan, initial ROI hypothesis, basic risk scan completed.

  2. Pilot

    Goal: Run a focused, time-boxed experiment to prove technical feasibility and measure initial impact.

    Milestones: reproducible training & evaluation notebook or pipeline, pre-registered success metrics, sufficient sample size for the target effect, monitoring & logging enabled, preliminary stakeholder feedback collected.

  3. Validate

    Goal: Independently validate model performance, reproducibility, and operational fit (including ethical and privacy checks).

    Milestones: independent validation run, model card & documentation, performance stability across cohorts, bias and privacy review, decision gate outcome (go/no-go/iterate).

  4. Scale

    Goal: Move from pilot to productionized deployment or broader integration with research processes.

    Milestones: production-ready pipelines, deployment runbook, monitoring & alerting, role handoffs, cost and resource plan, post-deployment evaluation plan.

Pilot planning template (copy & adapt)

Basic info

  • Pilot name
  • Owner / Research lead
  • Start / end dates
  • Stakeholders & reviewers
  • Primary research/workflow being augmented

Problem & hypothesis

Describe the specific problem, the AI intervention, and the measurable hypothesis (for example: "Using model X to triage samples will reduce manual review time by 30% while maintaining ≥95% sensitivity").

Success metrics

Define primary and secondary metrics. Examples:

  • Primary technical metrics: accuracy, AUC, precision/recall at operating point, calibration error
  • Operational metrics: time saved per task, throughput increase, percent automation
  • Reproducibility metrics: ability to rerun training and produce equivalent results, seed sensitivity
  • User & safety metrics: user satisfaction, false-positive cost, adverse outcomes

Sample size & power (practical guidance)

Estimate the sample size needed to detect a meaningful effect given expected variance and desired statistical power (commonly 80%). Use effect-size estimates from pilot data or domain knowledge. Where appropriate, use a power/sample-size calculator rather than ad hoc small-n tests. If labeled data are limited, consider stratified sampling, bootstrapped estimates, or an initial feasibility run to better estimate variance.

Experimental design & reproducibility

  • Train / validation / test split policy (dates, cohort definitions)
  • Version-controlled code and environment (container or environment lockfile)
  • Data lineage: input dataset versions, pre-processing steps
  • Random seeds recorded, model artifact storage location

Data & privacy considerations

List sensitive fields, consent constraints, de-identification plans, and any approvals required (IRB, data sharing agreements).

Logging & monitoring

Define what will be logged (predictions, inputs, timestamps, model versions) and where logs will be stored. Ensure logs support reproducibility and post-hoc audits.

Evaluation plan & cadence

How often will you evaluate performance during the pilot? Who reviews results and how are decisions documented?

Risk & validation checklist

  • Is the training data representative of the population the model will encounter?
  • Have you tested for known biases (demographic or cohort-based)?
  • Is the model stable across plausible data shifts?
  • Are data provenance and preprocessing fully documented and versioned?
  • Is the model reproducible from the stored artifacts and environment specifications?
  • Is there a plan to handle model failures or unexpected outputs (human-in-the-loop, fallback rules)?
  • Has privacy/legal/ethics review been completed where required?
  • Are resource and cost estimates for training/inference documented?
  • Is the pilot instrumented to capture both success metrics and potential harms?

Roles & responsibilities matrix (example)

RoleTypical responsibilities
Research LeadDefine hypothesis, own pilot outcomes, coordinate stakeholders
Data EngineerPrepare data pipelines, ensure lineage and reproducibility
Modeler / ML EngineerTrain models, tune hyperparameters, package artifacts
Validator / QAIndependent evaluation, runs validation experiments, documents results
Governance / Ethics ReviewerConduct risk & privacy review, approve deployment decisions
DevOps / MLOpsDeploy pipelines, monitoring, and rollback procedures
End Users / Domain ExpertsProvide operational feedback, evaluate utility and harms in context

Example pilot retrospective template

  1. Summary of outcomes vs. pre-registered success criteria
  2. Technical findings (performance, stability, reproducibility)
  3. Operational findings (time saved, workflow changes, user acceptance)
  4. Risks observed and mitigation effectiveness
  5. Data constraints discovered
  6. Decision: stop, iterate, or scale (include rationale)
  7. Next steps and owners

Scale checklist (if pilot passes)

  • Production deployment plan and runbook complete
  • Monitoring & alerting configured for performance drift and data issues
  • Automated retraining or scheduled reviews defined
  • Access control and model governance enforced
  • Costs, service-level expectations, and support responsibilities agreed
  • Knowledge transfer: documentation, training, and handoff to operating owners

Practical tips

  • Start with a narrow, well-scoped pilot that can be measured and reversed.
  • Pre-register success metrics to avoid retrospective moving of goals.
  • Instrument everything from day one—good telemetry enables faster diagnosis and trust.
  • Favor reproducible pipelines (versioned data, code, environment) over ad hoc notebooks for pilots you might scale.
  • Include domain experts early; technical metrics alone rarely capture operational utility or harm.

Where interactivity helps

Transform the pilot planning template, risk checklist, and retrospective into interactive forms so teams can save runs, compare pilots over time, and build organizational memory. Capture key fields via structured forms (pilot name, metrics, decision gate result) and store submissions so later analytics can identify high-yield AI opportunities.

Example next steps & templates to copy

1) Pilot planning spreadsheet or interactive form (fields above). 2) Reproducible training pipeline template (example CI/CD with artifact storage). 3) Validation notebook that an independent reviewer can run. 4) Model card template.

Use this playbook as a living template: keep what works, adapt measurements to your context, and capture lessons so future pilots require less discovery work. If you want, convert the planning template into an interactive form to collect pilot metadata and build a searchable history of experiments.

Discuss Ask the Librarian

Discussion

Comments and conversation will live here.